23 Best Sweet Potato Casserole Recipes
The turkey gets all the attention, but at plenty of holiday tables the sweet potato casserole is the dish people actually go back for. The trouble is picking a version. Marshmallow or pecan streusel? Fresh potatoes or canned yams? Oven or slow cooker?
This list of 23 sweet potato casserole recipes covers the whole argument. There are torched marshmallow classics, crunchy pecan streusels, three takes on the Ruth’s Chris steakhouse version, four slow cooker recipes that keep the oven free, and vegan and gluten-free options that hold their own at the holiday table. If green bean casserole is the other side dish on your menu, our Best Green Bean Casserole Recipes roundup covers that one too.
A quick note on how this list works. None of these recipes are ours. Each one comes from the food blog linked beneath it, and we have written a short description in our own words so you can compare styles fast. The ingredients, steps, and the cook’s own tips are all on the creator’s page, one click away. If one of these ends up on your table, give the credit where it belongs, with the blog that published it.
1. Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallow Fluff

Image: Sugar and Charm
Sugar and Charm starts with whole baked potatoes instead of boiled ones, then mashes them with butter, brown sugar, and heavy cream. There are no eggs in the filling. The top is homemade marshmallow fluff, torched until golden, for anyone who wants the marshmallow version done properly.
From Sugar and Charm: Get the Recipe →
2. Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallows and Pecans

Image: The Recipe Critic
A boiled potato base with brown sugar, butter, and cinnamon, and no eggs to fuss with. Chopped pecans get folded through the filling, then more pecans and a layer of marshmallows go over the top. It’s the classic holiday version, built for a crowd.
From Spend With Pennies: Get the Recipe →
3. Spiced Sweet Potato Casserole with Pecan Crumble and Marshmallows

Image: Kylee Cooks
The Chunky Chef leans into the spices here, with cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, and maple syrup warming up the filling. On top you get both finishes at once, a buttery pecan crumble and a scatter of mini marshmallows. Good pick when your table refuses to choose sides.
From The Chunky Chef: Get the Recipe →
4. Sweet Potato Casserole with Brown Sugar Streusel and Marshmallows

Image: RecipeTeacher
RecipeTeacher keeps the filling itself unsweetened, which sounds odd until you see the plan. All the sweetness lives in the brown sugar streusel, and toasted marshmallows finish the top. Each bite balances plain, earthy potato against that crunchy, sugary crust.
From RecipeTeacher: Get the Recipe →
5. Sweet Potato Casserole with Oat Crumb and Marshmallows

Image: Thank You Berry Much
Jewel yams are the base here, mashed into a smooth filling under two toppings at once. A brown sugar oat crumb brings the crunch, and marshmallows melt over everything. It suits cooks who want the streusel and the marshmallow without making two casseroles.
From Love From The Oven: Get the Recipe →
6. Easy Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallows

Image: MommaCan
MommaCan keeps this one simple enough for a weeknight practice run. Boiled potatoes, dark brown sugar, cinnamon, and pumpkin pie spice, with eggs for structure and the classic marshmallow top. Nothing fancy, and that’s exactly the point of it.
From MommaCan: Get the Recipe →
7. Sweet Potato Casserole with Pecan Streusel

Image: Little Broken
No marshmallows anywhere near this one. Little Broken boils the potatoes, folds in heavy cream for richness, and covers the top with a buttery pecan streusel made from flour, brown sugar, and cold butter. It’s the pick for the pecan loyalists at the table.
From Little Broken: Get the Recipe →
8. Sweet Potato Casserole with Brown Sugar Pecan Topping

Image: Tastes Better From Scratch
A traditional family style version from Tastes Better From Scratch. The filling uses boiled potatoes, evaporated milk, and eggs, so it sets up soft and custardy under a brown sugar pecan topping. This is the old fashioned version most holiday tables grew up with.
From Tastes Better From Scratch: Get the Recipe →
9. Streusel-Topped Sweet Potato Casserole

Image: Little Black Skillet
Little Black Skillet builds this on a Southern Living style base, with baked potatoes and half-and-half in the filling. The streusel is generous, a full two cups of pecans with brown sugar and butter. Expect a deep, nutty crunch in every spoonful.
From Little Black Skillet: Get the Recipe →
10. Sweet Potato Casserole with Caramelized Pecan Streusel

Image: GypsyPlate
GypsyPlate bakes the potatoes first, then adds eggs and nutmeg to the mash. The pecan streusel goes on halfway through the bake instead of at the start, so it comes out crisp and caramelized rather than soft. A small timing trick that changes the texture.
From GypsyPlate: Get the Recipe →
11. Gluten-Free Sweet Potato Casserole

Image: A Sweet Thyme
The gluten-free seat at the table is covered here. A Sweet Thyme roasts the potatoes, and the streusel uses a gluten-free 1:1 flour with toasted pecans, so it still bakes up crunchy. Nobody has to settle for a separate, lesser side dish.
From A Sweet Thyme: Get the Recipe →
12. Ruth’s Chris Sweet Potato Casserole

Image: The Recipe Critic
The Recipe Critic recreates the Ruth’s Chris steakhouse favorite at home. The filling is smooth and sweet under a brown sugar pecan crumble, the part everyone remembers from the restaurant. Make it when you want the steakhouse side without the steakhouse bill.
From The Recipe Critic: Get the Recipe →
13. Ruth’s Chris Sweet Potato Casserole with Praline Crumble

Image: 40 Aprons
40 Aprons also takes on the Ruth’s Chris version, but scales it down. About two cups of mash and one egg make a praline crumble topped casserole sized for a smaller holiday table. Same restaurant idea, no giant pile of leftovers for a week.
From 40 Aprons: Get the Recipe →
14. Ruth’s Chris Sweet Potato Casserole, Spiced

Image: Noshing with the Nolands
The third Ruth’s Chris take, and the warmest of the three. I’m Hungry For That adds cinnamon and nutmeg to the filling itself, so the spice runs through every bite instead of only the topping. Pick this one if the other copycats sound too plain.
From I’m Hungry For That: Get the Recipe →
15. Sweet Potato Casserole with Canned Yams and Marshmallows

Image: Princess Pinky Girl
Princess Pinky Girl starts with canned yams, so there’s no peeling or boiling at all. Eggs, dark brown sugar, a little cornstarch, orange juice, and nutmeg go into the mash, with mini marshmallows on top. It’s the shortcut classic for a busy holiday morning.
From Princess Pinky Girl: Get the Recipe →
16. Sweet Potato Casserole with Canned Yams and Pecan Crumble

Image: Mom’s Dinner
Mom’s Dinner also opens a can, using a full 40 ounces of yams with eggs and milk. A toasted pecan crumble goes on top instead of marshmallows, and the whole thing bakes in an 8×8 pan. A smaller batch that still feels like the real thing.
From Mom’s Dinner: Get the Recipe →
17. Crockpot Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallows and Pecans

Image: The Cookie Rookie
The Cookie Rookie keeps the potatoes cubed instead of mashed, simmering them in a brown sugar butter sauce right in the slow cooker. Marshmallows and pecans finish the top, and there are no eggs involved. Your oven stays free for everything else on the menu.
From The Cookie Rookie: Get the Recipe →
18. Crockpot Sweet Potato Casserole with Candied Pecans

Image: Jessica Gavin
Jessica Gavin mashes the potatoes right in the slow cooker, which saves a bowl and a step. A candied pecan topping adds the crunch, and marshmallows are there if you want them, but optional. Good for cooks who like the topping rules loose.
From Jessica Gavin: Get the Recipe →
19. Crockpot Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallows

Image: Pip and Ebby
The lowest effort version in the whole list. Pip and Ebby put raw sweet potato halves straight into the slow cooker, no boiling, no pre-cooking, nothing. A marshmallow top melts over at the end, and pecans are optional. Set it up and walk away.
From Pip and Ebby: Get the Recipe →
20. Crock Pot Sweet Potato Casserole with Canned Yams

Image: Everyday Family Cooking
Everyday Family Cooking pairs the slow cooker with canned yams for a double shortcut. One egg, a pecan crumble, and marshmallows round it out. It’s pantry cooking at its most practical, the version to remember when the holiday grocery run didn’t happen.
From Everyday Family Cooking: Get the Recipe →
21. Vegan Sweet Potato Casserole with Maple Pecan Praline

Image: Delish Knowledge
Delish Knowledge makes the vegan version with plant butter and non-dairy milk, plus fresh ginger grated into the filling for a little warmth. The topping is a maple pecan praline made with almond flour, so this one is gluten-free too.
From Delish Knowledge: Get the Recipe →
22. Vegan Sweet Potato Casserole with Candied Pecans and Marshmallows

Image: Thank You Berry Much
Thank You Berry Much bakes the potatoes, then blends them silky with vegan butter and oat milk. Both toppings show up here, candied pecans and toasted vegan marshmallows, and the whole recipe takes just eight ingredients. Proof the vegan version doesn’t have to feel like a backup plan.
From Thank You Berry Much: Get the Recipe →
23. Vegan Sweet Potato Casserole, Two Ways

Image: The Banana Diaries
The Banana Diaries leaves the topping choice up to you. The filling is baked potato with arrowroot, coconut cream, and maple syrup, and you finish it one of two ways, vegan marshmallow with pecans or a cinnamon streusel. Egg-free, dairy-free, and it can go nut-free too.
From The Banana Diaries: Get the Recipe →
How We Picked These Recipes
Every dish in this roundup had to earn its place. The criteria used when building the list:
- Both topping camps get a fair hearing: marshmallow, pecan streusel, and a few with both, because families are divided on this one and the list should settle the argument, not pick a side.
- More than one way to cook it: oven baked, canned yam shortcuts, and slow cooker versions, since oven space runs out fast on a holiday.
- Everyday grocery ingredients: nothing on these lists needs a specialty store, just a normal supermarket run.
- Clear steps on the creator’s page: amounts and bake times stated up front, so you know the plan before you start peeling.
- Room for everyone at the table: vegan and gluten-free versions included as real options, not as an afterthought.
A couple of habits help almost every version here. Cook the potatoes until they are fully soft before mashing, since undercooked sweet potatoes mash lumpy no matter how long you work at them. And add the topping near the end of the bake, or watch the last few minutes closely, because marshmallows go from golden to burnt in about a minute.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make sweet potato casserole ahead of time?
Yes, and most holiday cooks do. The usual approach is to make the filling a day or two early, refrigerate it in the baking dish, and add the topping just before it goes into the oven so the topping stays crisp. Several creators in this list include their own make-ahead notes on the recipe page.
Does sweet potato casserole need eggs?
No. Eggs give the filling a firmer, more custardy set, and plenty of recipes use them, but several versions in this list skip eggs completely, including the marshmallow fluff casserole at number 1 and the slow cooker casserole at number 17. Both styles work, so it comes down to the texture you like.
Can I use canned yams instead of fresh sweet potatoes?
Yes. Three recipes in this list start with canned yams, at numbers 15, 16, and 20, and they skip the peeling and boiling entirely. The flavor is a little milder than fresh, but with the brown sugar and toppings in play, most tables never notice.
Which topping is more traditional, marshmallow or pecan streusel?
It depends on where you grew up. Marshmallow topping is the classic most people picture, while pecan streusel is the longtime favorite across much of the South. This list includes plenty of both, plus a few recipes that use the two together, so you can settle the debate at your own table.
Can I freeze sweet potato casserole?
The filling freezes well on its own. Freeze it without the topping for the best texture, thaw it in the fridge overnight, then add fresh topping and bake. A few of the creators above share their own freezing and reheating notes on their recipe pages.
More Collections You’ll Love
This roundup is part of our Casseroles & Comfort Food Dinners collection, alongside our Best Green Bean Casserole Recipes, the other casserole no holiday table skips. Browse everything in the cluster so far on the Casseroles & Comfort Food Dinners category page, and save this post before the holiday cooking starts. Marshmallow or streusel, there is a version here with your name on it.
All recipes belong to their creators. Please visit their sites for the full recipes. Each photo is credited separately to its image source under the picture. Creator and want something changed or removed? See our Takedown & Copyright Policy.
